Window Won't Stay Up? How to Fix a Broken Window Balance

Window mechanism and hardware repair

You lift the window, let go, and it slides back down. Or it hangs open for a second and then slams shut. Either way, the window itself is almost never the problem.

A window that will not stay up has lost whatever holds the weight of the sash. In an old wood window that is a cord and a hidden iron weight. In most windows built after the 1960s it is a balance: a spring-loaded part in the side of the frame. Both are cheap to fix compared to a new window. Here is how to tell which one you have, what usually breaks, and what the repair costs in the Boston area.

Ropes or balances: check the side of the frame

Open the window as far as it goes and look at the side of the frame next to the sash.

  • You see a rope or chain running up into the top of the frame, or a pulley wheel near the top. That is a counterweight window, usually wood and usually built before the 1960s. When it will not stay up, a cord has broken or come off the pulley.

  • You see a tube, a metal channel or a plastic track running the full height of the side. That is a balance window, wood, vinyl or aluminum. When it will not stay up, a balance has failed or a shoe at the bottom of the sash has cracked.

If it is ropes, read Sash Cord & Weight Repair for Old Boston Windows or see our sash cord and pulley repair service. The rest of this post is about balances.

What fails in a balance window

  • A spiral balance unwinds. The twisted rod inside the tube loses tension, so it can no longer carry the sash. Common on vinyl and newer wood double-hungs.

  • A channel balance spring breaks. Older windows often have metal channels marked with a number like “24 HD”. When the spring goes, the sash drops. Many of these are no longer stocked and are made to order.

  • A pivot shoe cracks. On tilt-in windows a small shoe at the bottom of the sash rides inside the balance. When it cracks, the sash drops or will not tilt back in.

  • A coil balance wears out. Flat coiled springs at the top of the track lose their pull over the years.

One clue helps: if the sash drops on one side only and sits crooked, one balance or one shoe has failed. If the whole sash drops evenly, both sides are worn.

Can you fix it yourself?

Sometimes. A cracked pivot shoe on a common window is a part you can buy and swap in an afternoon. The hard part is matching it: balances come in many lengths and weight ratings, and the wrong one either will not hold the sash or makes it fly up. Channel balances on older windows often have to be ordered to the exact length and sash weight. If the label on the old balance is gone, measuring the metal part and weighing the sash is the only reliable way to order the right one.

Be careful taking one out. A balance is held under spring tension, and a spiral rod or coil spring can snap back hard when it is released. Lock the rod or clamp the spring before you unhook it.

Replace both sides of the sash together. The other balance is the same age and usually close to failing, and a sash with one new and one old balance does not run evenly.

What it costs in the Boston area

These are the prices we charge:

  • Spiral or channel balance: $125 per balance, $250 per sash for both sides.

  • Andersen balances: $345 per window.

  • Pivot shoe: $75 each.

  • Tune-up when nothing is broken but the sash binds: $65 per window.

There is a $150 minimum per visit, so a single pivot shoe or one tune-up is billed at the minimum. A replacement double-hung runs $800 to $2,500 installed. If the frame and glass are sound, a $250 balance repair keeps the window working for years. Stocked balances take under an hour per window. Made-to-order balances need a second visit once the part arrives.

The bottom line

A window that will not stay up needs a part, not a new window. Look at the side of the frame to see whether it has cords or balances, replace balances in pairs, and match the part to the window. If you would rather have it done, our page on window balance replacement lists every type we replace and what each costs. Send a photo of the window and the balance to admin@wholewindow.com and we will price it by email.